On May 7, at 7.30 in the evening, fisherman Kunnummal Saidalavi was stress-free at dwelling in Puthankadappuram when he received a name. A buddy, who sounded frantic, was on the line. He instructed Saidalavi {that a} boat had capsized in the Poorappuzha estuary in Tanur. Filled with dread realizing that his spouse and 4 youngsters had been amongst the passengers, Saidalavi rushed to the estuary, positioned about 10 km away. On reaching the financial institution of the river, he clambered right into a vessel to assist in rescue efforts. While he searched the darkish waters anxiously, a diver all of a sudden thrust a physique into his arms. It was his 13-year-old daughter, Shafna. Saidalavi’s wails pierced the darkness.
For a minute, even these scrambling by way of the rescue efforts stopped. “Those wails made us all weep. It was too much to bear,” says Harshad Cheruvath, a resident of the space. “He was crying saying, ‘This is my child; the others are in the water. I can’t leave without them,’” he remembers.
Just about an hour earlier, the boat, named Atlantic, carrying about 40 passengers, had capsized in Poorappuzha, a tributary of Kadalundipuzha. The tragedy passed off close to a newly developed vacationer spot alongside the coast. Cheruvath says the native individuals and personnel from the Department of Fire and Rescue Services struggled to succeed in the passengers trapped inside the boat, which was resting on the muddy riverbed. Twenty-two individuals, together with 15 youngsters and 5 girls, misplaced their lives in the incident close to Thooval Theeram seashore. All the passengers had been from Malappuram district. Nearly half the passengers who misplaced their lives had been from fisher households.
A day later, an eerie silence shrouds Saidalavi’s ramshackle dwelling at Puthankadappuram. Visitors stream in and out, expressing their sympathy and providing help. Saidalavi and his youthful brother Siraj, who can also be a fisherman, are in shock. Both of them have misplaced their wives and all their youngsters. Their sister, too, misplaced her two youngsters in the tragedy.
While Siraj, the blood seemingly drained from his face, sits quietly, Saidalavi regrets that his youngsters didn’t heed his warning. He says they referred to as him excitedly from the boat to inform him that that they had been given a profitable supply: purchase one ticket for a ship trip and get one other free. “I had told them not to get into that boat, but they had already been convinced,” he mourns. That had been their final dialog.
Searching for survivors
The activity of the search workforce was reduce out that night time. The rescuers had no thought how many individuals had received into the boat, which had a capability of about 25. There was neither a passenger chart nor a correct ticketing system. Safety had clearly been thrown to the winds from the begin.
The individuals of the space accuse Nasar P. Tanur, the boat operator, of changing an abnormal fishing boat with a round-bottomed hull right into a passenger vessel fitted with an higher deck, at a yard in Ponnani, by influencing the authorities. Ok.T. Chacko, chairman of the Kerala Shipping and Inland Navigation Corporation, says boats with fishing hulls shouldn’t be used for ferrying vacationers. “Fishing and passenger boats operate differently on water. Using fishing boats to carry passengers is risky,” he says.
Soon after the tragedy, Nasar went lacking. He was arrested later. So had been the boat crew who swam to security after the accident.
Local individuals and personnel of the Department of Fire and Rescue Services try to succeed in the passengers trapped inside the boat.
| Photo Credit:
SAKEER HUSSAIN
Atlantic additionally didn’t have permission to function past 6 p.m., say the police. Yet, it set out on its final journey from a makeshift jetty at Thooval Theeram round 6.45 p.m. Pratheesh, who was sitting on the seashore when the boat capsized, and whose video of the boat’s final journey went viral on social media, instructed The Hindu, “Even when the boat started from the jetty, it was tilting towards one side. We were scared. We just watched its movement. It capsized while taking a sharp turn in the middle of the river.”
The boat sank about 300 metres off Thooval Theeram, some quarter-hour after leaving the jetty. “Most passengers were flung to one side when it turned. Soon, we were all in the water. I hit my head against something, but I thankfully managed to escape with my little daughter,” says Rajisha, one in all the survivors. Rajisha’s youngster and husband survived as they had been carrying life jackets. She says solely 5 passengers, of which 4 had been youngsters, had worn life jackets on that ill-fated journey.
The efforts of the rescuers had been hampered by the darkness, the deep water, and the muddy backside of the river. Ambika, who noticed the boat sinking, says the lack of lights additionally hampered the rescue in the preliminary section. “We could hear music blaring from the boat. Suddenly I heard loud cries, and the boat’s lights started to dim. We shouted for help. Many local people jumped into the river and started swimming towards the boat,” she remembers.
The victims had been trapped inside the glass-panelled decrease deck of the boat. Some of the rescuers broke the glass panes with their palms to drag out the victims trapped inside, says Cheruvath. “Many of them didn’t realise they were bleeding from the wounds caused by broken glass and oyster shells,” he says.
The aftermath of the tragedy
Soon, the State equipment sprang into motion. The Minister of Tourism, P.A. Mohammed Riyas, and the Minister of Sports, V. Abdurahiman, commanded the search and rescue operations. As information of the tragedy unfold, individuals flocked to hospitals at Tanur, Tirur, Tirurangadi, and Kottakkal — all cities in Malappuram district — in search of their relations and buddies. Roads had been cleared for ambulances.
The State was placed on excessive alert. Doctors had been referred to as in from the neighbouring districts of Kozhikode and Thrissur to deal with the emergency. The demise toll rose to 22 by 11.30 p.m., when the boat was hauled out of the river. As doubts lingered about the complete variety of passengers in the vessel, groups of the Navy and the National Disaster Response Force got here the subsequent morning to conduct one other search. Just a few hours later, the search was referred to as off and the authorities declared that there have been no extra victims. As per authorities figures, there have been 37 passengers in the boat of which 22 died, 10 had been rescued with accidents, and 5 swam to security.
The postmortem of the victims was performed by 9 a.m. on May 8. The 11 victims of Saidalavi’s household had been buried in a row at Puthankadappuram. Chief Minister Pinarayi Vijayan led a line of Ministers to pay homage to the victims and introduced {that a} compensation of ₹10 lakh could be given to the kin of every sufferer. The Union authorities supplied ₹2 lakh, too. Health Minister Veena George assured psychological well being help to the survivors and the members of the family of the victims. The State Human Rights Commission filed a case and sought a report inside 10 days from the District Collector and the District Police Chief. The Kerala State Commission for Protection of Child Rights additionally demanded a report.
The boat which was packed past its capability sank about 300 metres off Thooval Theeram.
| Photo Credit:
SAKEER HUSSAIN
By this time, the individuals’s grief had given solution to anger. There are allegations that these in energy had been complicit in the flouting of security norms. Unconfirmed reviews mentioned officers had ignored complaints of irregularities towards Nasar. “There was a lapse on the part of the police. The municipal authorities too ignored the matter. This tragedy could have been averted,” says Ok. Raju, a former police superintendent from Tanur.
Anger quickly grew into rage: individuals burnt the makeshift boat jetty, one in all the many who have come up in the area these days, and protested outdoors a courtroom at Parappanangadi when Nasar was introduced there. They mentioned the tragedy was a results of his greed and callousness.
The authorities additionally introduced an inquiry by a judicial fee led by retired decide V.Ok. Mohanan. But this has not helped calm the agitated individuals of Tanur.
A historical past of warnings
Kerala has seen many boat tragedies. In 2002, in Kumarakom, a lush city identified for backwater tourism, 29 individuals, together with a nine-month-old child, had been killed in a ferry accident. In the Thattekkad tragedy of 2007, 18 individuals who had been on a college tour misplaced their lives. In 2009, a double-decker passenger boat sank in Thekkady killing 45 individuals, largely vacationers.
Judicial commissions had been set as much as examine these accidents. The commissions, led by M.M. Pareethu Pillai (Thattekkad), and E. Moideen Kunhu (Thekkady) and Ok. Narayana Kurup (Kumarakom), gave a number of suggestions to enhance security, however these stay on paper. Some of their recommendations embody organising a security commissioner for inland water transport, insurance coverage for all passenger boats, obligatory use of life jackets, and stringent motion towards officers accountable for a tragedy.
The boat after it was hauled out of the river.
| Photo Credit:
SAKEER HUSSAIN
Most individuals imagine that Tanur was a tragedy foretold. Just a few weeks earlier than the disaster, Muralee Thummarukudy, an skilled in disaster administration and an operations supervisor at the Crisis Management Branch of the United Nations Environment Programme, had warned of an imminent houseboat tragedy in the State. Thummarukudy had mentioned that the State wants a water security coverage, not only one on boat security. “We can reduce accident deaths in Kerala by two-thirds by sensibly applying the technical know-how and the systems currently available in the world,” he had mentioned. He had urged individuals to be extra aware of security. Thummarukudy had additionally highlighted the absence of correct briefings in houseboats, the lack of skilled drivers, and the penalties of boats not having licences.
Boat accidents in Kerala have claimed about 200 lives in the final 20 years. The State has an enormous community of inland waterways with super tourism potential, nevertheless it has been evident again and again that there have been compromises on security. As per official information, 3,213 inland vessels are in operation in the State’s waterways, however trade insiders say there are an estimated 4,000 vessels, together with unlicensed ones. There isn’t any fool-proof mechanism to detect unlawful inland vessels. The Kerala Inland Vessels Rules of 2010 and the Kerala Maritime Board Act of 2017 have been poorly enforced. The Kerala Maritime Board is the nodal company to make sure health, licensing, and secure operation of all vacationer vessels in the State, together with houseboats. But it doesn’t have an uniformed enforcement wing. Recommendations to type particular police items beneath a deputy superintendent of police stay on paper. The police, too, don’t have a mechanism to maintain a tab on vessels flouting norms.
Naval architects have repeatedly requested all boat operators to prominently show the carrying capability and registration on the vessel, however these pleas have fallen on deaf ears. Naval architect Paulson Joseph, a member of the Kerala Maritime Board-approved consultants panel, says accidents are preventable if boat builders and operators adhere to authorised designs and security norms. “If they don’t, insurance firms can reject compensation claims in case of accidents. More catamaran ferries must be introduced, since single-hull vessels that have inadequate width are a safety hazard,” he says.
A “free-for-all situation” prevails in many distant areas the place vacationer boats function, says Professor Ok. Sivaprasad, Department of Ship Technology, Cochin University of Science and Technology. “This can be prevented if local bodies have a stake in regulating boat operations. There must be curbs on having an upper deck. The government must appoint an adequate number of naval architects so that enforcement is foolproof. It must also publish a list of authorised vessels online so that travellers can verify the safety status of the boats they board,” he says.
In the wake of the Tanur tragedy, the All Kerala Houseboat Owners’ Federation has repeated its demand that the Kerala Maritime Board and the State tourism division take pressing steps to carry erring kettuvallam (houseboat) operators accountable. “Houseboats are a huge draw in Alappuzha and Kumarakom. The tourism department has a scheme of classifying houseboats to assess their safety and service standards and to provide government aid accordingly. Only a small percentage of houseboat operators have chosen to subscribe to this despite regular accidents,” says an trade insider.
While ferries and vacationer boats operated by authorities businesses largely adhere to security norms, equivalent to preserving an satisfactory variety of life jackets, lifebuoys, and buoyant equipment, non-public operators are beneath no compulsion to comply with swimsuit. Further, as Thummarukudy identified, there are hardly any security briefings for the passengers on board.
The individuals of Tanur say they raised a hue and cry when Atlantic started carrying vacationers alongside the Poorappuzha just a few weeks in the past. Following complaints, the police stopped the service for a day, however allowed providers to renew the subsequent day.
Saidalavi says his youngsters had been good college students and had dreamed of constructing him a correct home. “I had taught them how to swim, but they got stuck under the boat. And I have lost everything I had,” he mourns.
